The Roots vs The Flower

I think that the most important issue that we need to grapple with in American today is, what kind of racism continues to exist? In my opinion, claims on either end of the spectrum lack legitimacy, i.e. we are not experiencing a more camouflaged version of Institutional racism but we are not experiencing Incidental racism by a few bad apples either. Rather, we are experiencing a racial bias within the fabric of our society. It is of the same variety that James Baldwin describes in his great debate with William F. Buckley (below). Thus, for example, the notion that the police are, in effect, patrolling the border between black and white communities is not only an inaccurate depiction but also a counter-productive one, as it tilts the frame towards a kind of Institutional racism that does not exist. As well, the notion that policing is uniformly applied across black and white communities, and the disproportionate representation of African Americans in the criminal justice system is as a result of disproportionate criminal activity is an equally inaccurate and counter-productive depiction, as it glosses over a much more militarized and aggressive form of law enforcement that has evolved in high-crime, high-poverty communities, which are typically black communities. The question remains, how do we address a racial bias in the fabric of our society? I do not think it can be addressed by asking white America to take ownership of sins that they have not committed and ask forgiveness for views that they do not hold (as an aside, I would not be considered 'white' by the normal standard, as I am half Indian). This is under the assumption that the vast majority of white Americans are not overt or covert racists, and do not commit racist acts by commission or omission. This may or may not be the case, but, given that it is not a supposition that can be derived from hard data, I think that we would be much better off assuming it is the case. In my view, the only path forward is to re-frame this debate on Individual terms, and adopt measures that benefit all Individuals, even as they will, in fact, benefit African Americans disproportionately. This tracks to the classic answer that Barack Obama gave in a debate, whereby, when asked how he will address the socioeconomic woes of African Americans, he replied that he would address the socioeconomic woes of all Americans, and African Americans would enjoy an incidental, disproportionate benefit by virtue of their more challenging circumstances. To get there, I think that it will be important for everyone to rally around a common cause for preserving Individual life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness, without regard to color, but with full knowledge that, in doing so, they will address the disparities of color within our economy, politics and criminal justice system. This would entail enforcing policies of deescalation and removing criminal liability protections in policing, fixing upside-down voting districts, investing in education and economic enterprise zones, etc, but also enforcing a more uniform code of Individual responsibility and accountability, like eliminating the welfare state and reverse discrimination, such that all Americans that need help can get it, but all Americans are, ultimately, on a level playing field. Rather than burning calories on continually fixating the racist roots of America, let’s focus the measures that will produce a non-racist flower ;-)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPz7kTnEWKE&t=975